I have to agree with Pleuni the pros outweigh the cons! pre-print and a strict open data policy should be the rule rather then the exception!
One of the best things about working at Stanford is having lunch outside with my colleagues almost every day. Last Friday it was fairly cold (70 degrees orso, 20°C) but we are a tough bunch and we were sitting outside.
One of the newer people in the lab asked to the others: “do you publish your manuscripts on the arXiv?” What followed was a brief discussion of the pros and cons of publishing on the arXiv before a paper is published in a journal. Here is my summary.
Pros and cons of publishing on the arXiv
1. Science goes faster when we share our results faster.
2. Published papers will be better if more people can give feedback early on.
3. There is some evidence (though not from a randomized trial) that papers get cited more when they are first published on the arXiv.
4. Getting your paper “out…
View original post 472 more words